Sunday, January 18, 2009

Landsacpe narratives

The green regime

"The land of Israel was a virgin land to be possessed. The land of Israel was perceived as a clean slate, a tabula rasa, as raw material awaiting the sculptor…" [p.25, Sharon Rotbard "The mold of Israeli architecture"; Segal (2002) A civil occupation]

From day one the Zionist organizations set a goal to fill the empty land. One of the main landscape filling was extensive forestation. we can still see the old Israeli border from 1948 to 1967 (which is officially known as the green line) as the edge of the planted forest.


We can look at the park as extension of the Israeli green occupation.
















Narratives of Landscape:
“In order to change a city, its enough to change the city story”
[Sharon Rotbard "white city,black city"]
Except for the fight over the land physical appearance there is a fundamental fight over the story behind the landscapes. We can look at the Israeli landscape as an ongoing battlefield of chronic erasing, renaming, and re-writing of landscape. In addition to these processes there is an ongoing development of tools that aim to remember, rewriting, reconstructing and remap the memory of the hidden, forgotten landscapes .During time a verity of strategies were created in order to link a certain narrative to a certain place. Renaming streets, publishing books, redrawing old maps, web pages (Google earth), on-site events, conservation and reconstruction, archeology excavations are all part of the war over the dominant narrative.
Here are some examples:

http://www.nakbainhebrew.org/index.php?lang=english
http://www.palestineremembered.com/
http://www.jstory.co.il/

After understanding these processes we can now look at the ' not very conscious' generic park as an erasure of all past narratives and the 'democratic space for interaction' as a past-less future-less space that holds no identity.

the middle of the old city of jaffa is now a touristic park

"…Narratives are also there in landscapes. In various ways, stories “take place” . Landscapes not only locates or serves as backgrounds settings for stories, but itself a changing, eventful figure and process that engenders stories"
“In turn, every narrative, even the most abstract, allegorical or personal, plays a critical role in making places. It is true narrative that we interpret the process and events of place. We come to know a place because we know its stories. “
Besides transforming place through association, the narratives of events, or even fiction and myth , are “written” into the physical form of the landscape , becoming concrete, tangible… real. (Landscape Narrative)


A nice example for such an art work is of Ronen Eidelman how used a soccer field line maker to draw the lost street of manshya over the existing park





http://ronen.dvarim.com/2007/10/07/marking-manshia-pictures/

If architecture is a 'speculation in space' can we consider a creation of narratives and linking them to certain place architecture?
Can we use these story telling strategies to create a new space or layer over the park without changing it's physical scape?

“Like a language, narrative is a means of communicating. The selecting and sequencing of events to construct a meaningful story can be homologous to the selecting of words to form a meaningful sentence. Changing the order in which events are told in a story , changes the meaning of the story.” (Landscape narrative, page 4)

Parks- a constantly changing landscape , a constantly changing history


This interpretation of landscape can be seen in two ways like Kuba suggested:
show the absurdity of the process (a fake history maybe) or seeing it as an opportunity for a positive act.



-“Every city park has a history. But this is not an historical study. It is based on the principle that parks, like cities, are constantly developing and never completed. “ (Great Cities Parks/ Alan Tate 1-2)
-Once the park is established we can think of it as an empty history container that points the constant change and development. The constant changing of a park and its location can be a path, a vital space of development, of change, A possible future!
-Sir Geoffry Jellice suggested that the continuing purpose of public parks ‘should be to lift people out of the everyday life’ (2) the existence of park is crucial to the community as a temple. As a center of gathering. The park can be seen as the modern acropolis.

The possible futures

We decide to search for the lost narrative of the park:

- The great bay
During the years there was a public discourse over the issues of use of territory in the area of the ‘Garbidge hill’ in Yafo . The organization Yaffo Yafat Yamim , was fighting in order to change the park design , creating a great bay which will bring the waterfront to the city.

"The alchemist of "minhal mekarkaey Israel" tries to turn garbage into gold"


"This is the Israeli way of thinking, not making a difference between man & nature – if there is a sealine as beautiful as "habonim" or an ancient port - then we should fill it up with garbage."

http://shezaf.net/zope/home/he/3/1138306020/

http://shezaf.net/zope/home/he/3/1183133079/



-patriot rockets where situated at the park during the second golf war



JAFFA, ISRAEL - MARCH 4: A U.S. soldier guides a Patriot anti-missile missile into place as Patriot batteries are deployed March 4, 2003 on Jaffa beach near Tel Aviv. The batteries, supplied and operated by U.S. troops, are a back-up system to the Israeli Arrow missile killer meant to protect the densely populated center from the potential threat of Iraqi Scud missiles. (Photo by David Silverman/Getty Images)





No comments:

Post a Comment